Question about rare lip gloss?

Yes, im about 99% positive its the same thing. HSN and discount stores buy a lot of excess inventory from companies. The thing about them only selling 500 of them, was probably also just a business scheme so everyone would rush to buy them, companies are known to do that. But anyways, yes its very likely that its the same. When Escada Moon Sparkle perfume came out i bought three of them, thinking because it was limited edition i would never see it again, but i see them all over still.